Each month Florida Rental By Owners (FlaRBO) is excited to introduce one of our incredible hosts. They share their story of what inspired them to open up their home to travelers. Our April host is Paul McWilliams who owns a beautiful beachfront vacation rental on Siesta Key, Florida. Paul discloses his insider tips about the best that’s offered at this favorite Gulf of Mexico destination. And why his property is one of the most sought-after condos on the West Coast.

What inspired you to start hosting your Florida Vacation Rental?

Sherri (my wife) and I have vacationed at some of the world’s most spectacular beaches during our 43 years of marriage. We knew exactly what we wanted and realized it would not be easy to find.  We searched for three years before selecting the condo we own today on Siesta Key, Florida.  Siesta Key is a barrier island off the coast of Sarasota, which is about midway between Tampa and Ft. Myers. We bought our condo with hosting as one of our primary goals.  While we were confident that vacationers would find our unique balance of isolation and convenience attractive. This was our first venture into the short-term vacation rental industry. I don’t mind saying, we were more than a little nervous.

Shortly after we bought the condo we totally remodeled it with a focus on perfecting the stunning waterfront views. One of the first items on our must-have list was maximizing our oceanfront Lanai. We added floor-to-ceiling sliding glass panels and a glass rail versus the more traditional picket fence rail.  With this, we have unobstructed views of the beach and Gulf of Mexico to the west and south.  It is now the perfect ambiance for morning coffee and a front row seat to unbelievable sunsets. We also tackled the master suite to maximize the stunning ocean view. We wanted to create an ambiance where stress would melt away as the sound of the waves. Lulling you to sleep at night. 

How do you exceed your Guest’s Expectations? Why do they keep coming back?

To explain our success is the old saying; “If you love what you do, you will do it well”.  Vacations have always been a big thing for us.  When we were young we often had to scrimp and save for two years between vacations.  However, creating new memories was and still is far more important to us than buying new stuff. 

We look at every single one of our guests through this lens.  We take the time to learn about what they like. What their expectations are and then do what we can to ensure they have a great vacation.  While we do many unique things to realize this goal, I think our caring is what makes the largest difference.  We are not just focusing on providing a dwelling. Our focus is to help facilitate a vacation experience that our guests will hopefully remember for a lifetime. For families with kids, we suggest activities that provide great opportunities for interaction and bonding.  Our theme, if you will, is “Get Away and Get Together.”  

In addition to doing what we can to help our guests plan and enjoy their vacation. We also give them first dibs on booking the same week(s) in the following year.  Many of our guests really like this perk – this year we’re already over 80% booked and nearly 45% of our reservations are from returning guests.

Why are you Passionate about your Host of the Month – Siesta Key Rental?

Location, location, and location!! During our three-year search, we drove literally every road that goes to the beach between Anna Maria Island and Marco Island – essentially the entire Gulf coast south of Clearwater Beach.  Along the way, we walked miles of beach and evaluated well over a dozen condos in various locations. 

The location we chose is literally unique.  We are on a VERY narrow strip of sand that is only about 350 feet wide.  Our condo sits directly on the beach and is oceanfront without compromise.  The Gulf of Mexico is only about 125 feet to our west. The bay inlet is a similar distance to the east. Along the bayside are boat docks, a kayak storage rack and a kayak launch that our guests can use. The quiet southern end of Siesta Key is where seashells and birds are far more plentiful than tourists. We love our unique and un-crowded beach environment.

Our guests can take advantage of the free Breeze Trolley that stops right by us. It’s a short walk to restaurants, entertainment, and activities. We also love to take long beach walks. The feel of the sand and sound of the surf help wash away the pressures of life and reset our priorities. During our walks, we watch a variety of shorebirds. Ospreys, Seagulls, and Pelicans dive for food. If I’m carrying a fishing pole, a Blue Herring will follow close behind looking for a free meal.  Sherri loves the fact that this is by far the best place for finding seashells, sea glass and fossilized shark teeth on Siesta Key.

We’ve averaged roughly 95% occupancy and have not had a vacant week since mid-December 2016.  More importantly, we are having an absolutely wonderful time meeting people from around the world. Helping them create vacation memories that we hope will last a lifetime. 

 Insider Tip!

Our bay inlet is the conduit used by kayak tour companies to reach the mangrove islands, loaded with birds. It’s just a short paddle to the south.  The fishing on the bayside is great too. There is a place where you can beach and walk over to the Gulf.  If you’ve got the stamina, you can cross the bay to Spanish Point for lunch and refreshments (great Bloody Mary).

What are Reasons for Your Success as Host of the Month – Siesta Key?

While anyone can learn the mechanics of renting. To kick it up a notch, from there requires passion and an inherent love of people that runs deep.  I think it’s also very important to provide an accurate representation of the rental property and location.  For example, when I get an inquiry from someone that wants to be in the middle of the action, I suggest alternatives on the busier northern part of Siesta Key.

Of course, if there’s not a foundation of sound operations, none of those things will matter.  The whole idea is to never have problems. So a nearly obsessive regime of preventive maintenance, attention to detail and a backup plan are mandatory.

For these rare situations, we are very fortunate to have onsite staff six days a week  with 24/7 support.  We are even more fortunate that they care for our guests just like we would. We have absolutely great staff!! 

Insider Tips for Siesta Key

Why do you recommend Siesta Key for the perfect Florida vacation?

First and foremost, we are a get-away-from-it-all, smack-dab on the beach, Gulf in your face location.  For us, this is what beach vacationing is all about. Miles of open beach to walk, no crowds, tons of seashells to collect and fish to catch. Maybe just sitting cozily in a beach chair and the sound of the surf in the background. 

As a bonus, we’re far enough south that the Gulf water doesn’t get too cold in the winter. It warms quickly in the spring. For us, this is beachfront at its best.  However, that doesn’t mean we are the universal perfect answer for everyone.

What would be the perfect Itinerary for a stay in your home?

I also don’t think there is a one-size-fits-all perfect itinerary.  Some of our guests just want to hang on the beach and have no interest in wandering far. We provide from the beach chairs, umbrella, and cooler.  Other guests want to explore and do it all, and there is certainly plenty to do.  Our charter is to help as much or as little as our guests want.

Beyond the beach there are a ton of things to do and places to see in our area.  And, at night there are great restaurants and a number of choices for live entertainment. Siesta Key is surprisingly cosmopolitan, yet also “Midwestern” friendly.

What are some Things to Do?

To support our guests and help them build anticipation for their upcoming vacation. We developed what we call our Siesta Key Vacation Guide.  With this, our guests can navigate like locals and enjoy the hidden gems of Siesta Key and Sarasota.  The Guide is over 35 pages long. It includes detailed information about various topics like our favorite dishes at over 30 great restaurants. 

• Restaurants
• Grocery, butcher and fish markets
• Quick supply stop – for coffee addicts and more
• Shopping
• Golf
• Tennis
• Fishing
• Where to rent boats, jet-skis, kayaks, paddle-boards (SUP), etc.
• Things you can do for free
• Kid Activities
• Things to consider packing
• Travel Information
• Getting around Siesta Key and Sarasota

Describe your vacation rental or guest experience in 3 words.

Stimulate your senses!

Who would you recommend your property to?

The majority of our guests want to avoid the crowds of tourists that flock to most Florida destinations. They crave the ocean and want to be directly on the beach and as close to the water as possible. In our opinion, this is beachfront at its best.

Why does your property stand out from the Crowd?

• Location, location, location
• It is the closest condo to the Gulf of Mexico on Siesta Key
• Our condo is totally updated with glass railing providing unobstructed Gulf views
• There are miles and miles of open beach to walk, and to a mile or so of totally undeveloped beachfront
• Our area offers the best shelling and the best fishing on Siesta Key
• Our condo is the only one I know of on the southern Gulf that is direct oceanfront and direct bayside
• Guests have free use of boat docks, kayak storage rack, and kayak launch
• Our bedrooms have high-end Jamison king-size pillow-top beds that are superior to what the Marriott hotel chain offers

We realize we cannot be all things to all people, and we don’t try to be that.  What we strive for is presenting what we have accurately.  This and getting an understanding of a traveler’s expectations is why we always like to talk to people. We like the phone versus communicating only by email. 

This is one of the reasons we discontinued advertising on sites like HomeAway and VRBO.  Not only do they block any ability to communicate with travelers by phone. They filter out our website address in email communications. They also add traveler charges that average $150 or more per week for our condo.  We are very appreciative of the open communication policy embraced by FlaBRO.com. We like the fact there are no extra charges or booking fees common on the larger websites today.

________________________________________________

Interested in visiting Siesta Key, Florida?

You can view Paul and Sherri’s 2-bedroom beachfront condo here. Take advantage of booking direct today (sleeps up to 6). Don’t hesitate, this beachfront condo books up to one-year in advance!

____________________________________________

Browse and Book more vacation rentals on Florida Rental By Owners.

Florida’s #1 Owner Preferred Website. No Traveler Fees, No Commissions, and Direct Communication with the Owner always gets you the best price.